How to Parent Yourself
Everyone eventually must contend with the metaphorical challenge of becoming their own parent. It’s a challenge that is worthwhile because it turns you into a more confident and genuine version of yourself. It turns you into the author of your fate, the one who is actively involved in creating it instead of being the passive recipient of it.
For some people, becoming their own parent is a process of mimicking the example that was set by those who came before them. They take the values and beliefs that were instilled into them and carry on with them, using them to inform and guide the way they live. People's values are often the remnants of the care they received from their parental figures. They are links in a familial chain that stretches back to a time before their existence.
But, this linkage rarely goes uninterrupted. It is not easy to transmit values and more often than not, the process of becoming one’s own parent involves unlearning rather than imitating the rules that have been placed on you. At bare minimum it requires an examination of the values that one carries, some of which may have produced painful wounds that one has had to learn to live with.
Healing is more than an emotional term. It is an act of taking responsibility. It demands taking ownership of yourself, which means recognizing that you are the only person that is truly responsible for taking care of your needs. Early in life people look to their parents and caregivers to play this role, but if they are absent or even worse, when they are present but still negligent, resentment can start to set in. Resentment is a hard emotion. It can be inaccessible, and it is difficult to rid oneself of it once you have it.
Becoming your own parent can remedy the urge to beg and plead for help from false sources of support, and stop you from keeping hope alive well beyond what is appropriate or necessary. It is a process of psychological growth and maturation that helps you to become less self-absorbed (self-absorption is always a cover for feelings of insecurity) and become more capable of giving and receiving without ulterior motives.
Understanding the Concept
The idea of becoming your own parent is a metaphor that is rooted in developmental psychology and relates to the work of the attachment theorists like John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth. From their perspective, parents did more than provide nurturance and care for their children, or engage in idle play with them. Through the quality of their bond, parents were graphing psychological templates onto their children which served as a form of protection for them as they ventured out into the world. It is as if parents are placing their care into their children via some sort of osmosis, which allows children to intuitively call upon this source in moments of turmoil, doubt, and confusion.
There are many examples of this kind of protective bond in fiction. In Harry Potter, the relationship between Harry and his mother Lily is an example of this process of loving transference. The bond they shared by virtue of Lily’s love for Harry served as a form of protection that made Harry impervious to all manner of threats, even when he was not in her presence. The fact that she was gone did not lessen its force because Harry had internalized it and was capable of accessing it at times of need.
Parenting yourself means providing yourself with the boundaries, discipline, love, and compassion that you needed as a child and still need as an adult. All of which are necessary to effectively relate to yourself and others.
People mistakenly assume that boundaries are for other people when they are really for themselves. Boundaries are agreements people make with themselves about what they are willing to tolerate and accept, and when it comes to setting boundaries and standing up for themselves, they need discipline to follow through. They need discipline to do hard things and prioritize their well-being, especially when it would be more convenient not to. And they need compassion because without it people would be too hard on themselves and would never have the strength to take risks and try again when they fail.
Along with strength there is a certain humility that comes with a person realizing that what they wanted from their loved ones at the age of 10, they still want at the age of 30 or 40, or even 60. The beauty of adulthood is that memory allows people to travel back and recognize what unmet needs are still alive in them now, and they can use the resources they now have to give themselves what they always wanted.
This journey back is especially important and arduous for those who have suffered the insults and slights of being raised by the immature, the abusive, and the absentminded. These are the people who are most in need of a new way to relate to themselves, one that is not an internalized image of what was done to them in the past.
Psychological Foundations
People cling to the templates they receive early in life because they are unaware of them and at the same time overly invested in them. They are not, in a general sense, unaware of the fact that people can change, but they act as if this possibility does not exist for them.
Should this assumption be tested, people are loath to admit the error in their thinking, which reveals the depth of their fear more than their stubbornness. It is second nature to protest the lack of love that is available to us while completely ignoring the innumerable sources from which love can be derived and the numerous ways that love can be experienced. It is terrifying to face the reality that love is readily available, through other people, through nature, through art, and through the relationship we have with ourselves.
People stake their entire lives on whether or not they receive love and care from one particular person and place themselves at risk of being shattered if it does not happen. We cannot help but rely on the people around us in our infancy, which may be how we develop our doubts, insecurities, and negative habits, but it is also how we survive. Regardless of how positive or negative a person’s upbringing was, true secure attachment, in the most mature sense, is achieved through expansion and a proliferation of multiple life-giving relationships.
Far too often people isolate and repress themselves instead of reaching for growth and expansion. They force themselves to live in darkness and psychological decay, without warmth or acknowledgement. Parenting yourself is a means of protecting the parts of yourself that are still child-like and in need of help. The parts of yourself that exist in the shadows.
Why Becoming Your Own Parent is Necessary
Adults who are lost children suffer from all the common maladies–they are anxious, they people please and lack boundaries, they are full of self-doubt and lack any positive self-concept. All that is good and potent in them is overshadowed and wrecked by the harmful messages they received in dysfunctional families.
The only way to get in touch with a healthy version of themselves is by learning to provide the security, support, resilience, and trust they need to themselves. No one else can do it for them–not friends or family, not spouses or therapists, and most bitterly, not parents, who may one day be capable of change, but are still unable to change the past.
How to Start Parenting Yourself
The first step in re-parenting yourself is reflecting and identifying the gaps in your experience. No one gets everything they want from childhood (or from any period of life for that matter), but there is a difference between minor gaps in one’s experience that can easily be ignored and fissures that threaten the foundation of one’s life.
Because children are naturally egocentric and assume everything is about them, it is easy to fill those gaps with self-doubt and criticism. Children over-estimate their contributions to the problems they face and underestimate the frailties of the adults in their lives. They take on the tone of a harsh critic and incorporate that voice into themselves, and the inner critic lies in wait, ready to pounce at a moment’s notice and remind people of their defectiveness and the total responsibility they bear for their problems. A person who engages in deep reflection can look at the fissures and the gaps and fill them with care rather than cover them over with self-attacks. They can speak to themselves with a voice that is honest and true, especially about the things that are difficult, but do so from a place of empathy and compassion.
The inner voice is a mixture of the thoughts and opinions of others and in order to change the tenor of this voice one must be mindful of the outside voices they pay attention to and allow into their world.
Learn to say no sometimes. No to unsolicited feedback or advice. No to honesty without tact. No to the harmful projections that people put on you out of their own insecurities and inability to tolerate their emotions. Be intentional about what you seek out and what you allow.
Becoming one’s own parent doesn’t mean staunch individualism and total self-reliance. It means practicing discernment about who you share your life with.
It is the Relationship that Heals: Freedom, Encounter, and the Heart of Psychotherapy
Two popular therapeutic maxims can be found if you read Irvin Yalom’s Existential Psychotherapy.
The first maxim states that “the goal of psychotherapy is to bring the patient to the point where he can make a free choice.” The second maxim is a simple reminder that “it is the relationship that heals.”
If you work long enough as a psychotherapist you will hear these maxims restated in multiple ways, all of which contain the same essential truth, but I find it helpful to return to this version of them. The practice of psychotherapy is complex, which is why Yalom also says a separate and distinct psychotherapy is needed for each patient. There’s truth in that as well.
Most people are probably unaware of the fact that multiple research studies have shown that the quality of the therapeutic relationship is the strongest indicator of therapeutic success, by a wide margin. Some therapists work hard to make their patients think otherwise. They would like to convince patients that there is a single technique that can lead to growth and healing, even when data doesn’t actually support this claim.
The real question, which these maxims are alluding to, is why does the therapeutic relationship matter so much? Why is it more important than therapeutic technique?
The Complexity of Free Choice
We can start to answer that question by looking at Yalom’s first maxim and his notion of helping patients to make a free choice. Most people assume they don’t need any help in this matter. They make choices daily, which testifies to the fact that they are free individuals, and in a literal sense this is true, but a closer look reveals the relationship between freedom and choice is more tenuous, more complicated.
Freedom implies more than being able to act without opposition. Freedom implies awareness of the psychological forces and inner motives that underlie one’s decisions, as well as an awareness of the consequences of those decisions. To be free a person has to claim agency over their choices so that they become self-determined, which is more difficult than it seems. Anyone who studies themselves long enough will realize that many of the choices they take for granted are at least partially, if not wholly influenced by external factors. People look to friends, family, complete strangers, and everywhere else for guidance. There’s nothing wrong with considering the actions of others, but most go a step further and allow their choices to be based solely on other people’s thoughts and opinions.
Clinical Implications
Psychotherapy is unique amongst the helping professions precisely because it does not seek to satisfy the patient’s desire for easy answers. Instead, psychotherapy provides a space for people to grapple with their own thoughts and feelings and arrive at their own answers. Therapy is a space where choice becomes possible rather than prescriptive.
There is a dizzying effect when people start to peel back the layers of their own existence and discover parts of themselves sitting at the center of their existence, covered in conditions, but still capable of giving them the awareness they need to make their own free decisions. Passing through this stage of psychological vertigo is necessary in order to experience the freedom that exists on the other side.
It is the Relationship that Heals
After ten years in this profession, the idea that “it is the relationship that heals” seems self-evident. Most of the patients I’ve worked with have never praised me for my interventions or clinical acumen. Which is not to say that neither is relevant, but time and time again, patients have made it known that what is most important to them is the way I relate to them.
This is true for most therapists. The support we provide and the trust we instill through therapy is more important than any interpretation, technique, or orientation. In truth, these things are only useful if they allow us to establish a real connection with our patient, without which any and all therapeutic interventions would be rendered ineffective.
Emotional Demands of Therapeutic Practice
The psychotherapy relationship is a new kind of relational encounter, and it succeeds by providing the patient with a corrective emotional experience. One that is defined by presence, authenticity, and mutual recognition. The relationship is the mechanism of change, and its effectiveness hinges on the therapist's ability to be with their own humanity and use it as an instrument of healing.
Reflecting on all of this reaffirms my belief that the demands of being a therapist are misunderstood, including by therapists themselves. These demands are intense and constant—therapists are required to be self-aware, emotionally available, and tolerant of uncertainty well beyond what is required of the average person. By necessity patients are unaware of this burden, but therapists are never far from it.
People come to therapy with the hopes of being fixed. If they stay long enough past the disappointment of realizing that’s not what therapy is about, they can gain something of greater value. An opportunity to meet themselves. An opportunity to be seen and heard and understood in the context of a relationship that restores their dignity and full humanity. A relationship where healing comes from connection and not solely from correction.
Both maxims speak to the view of psychotherapy as a practice whose foundation is based on the willingness to meet another person where they are at. It is a view worth preserving.
AI and Human Responsibility
As we move further into a world in which artificial intelligence is a part of everyday life, we must consider the psychological effects this technology is having on us individually and collectively. We have to keep asking ourselves what we want this technology to be, how we want to shape it and how we are willing to be shaped by it.
There is a fight going on currently between the United States government and Anthropic, one of the major AI tech companies. Though the debate centers on the government's ability to use Anthropics AI technology in its military operations, the outcome of this fight will have major implications for the relationship between humanity and artificial intelligence.
There is a contingency within the government that wants to fast-track the implementation of AI into military operations. This contingency, made up of government officials and military officers, view AI as a way to more effectively deliver violence. Such thinking reveals an underlying belief in the inevitability of violence, and perhaps in their mind, the worthwhileness of violence as an objective.
The military, like other organizations grappling with AI, must give significant thought to the potential human cost of developing AI without regard for the psychological effects this technology is having on individuals and communities. Some people think AI is dangerous, and this view may be justified as there does appear to be a dark and destructive vision of AI forming in some segments of the government. Military officials who support this vision view AI as a tool that can enhance and augment the ability to inflict mass destruction without being hampered by ideological constraints.
I’m struck by that phrasing—without ideological constraints—struck by how disingenuous they are. Ideologies are simply systems of ideas, they are a specific manner of thinking, and even the most vague and ill-defined patterns of thought can represent some form of them.
The dream of an AI that allows someone to operate without ideological constraint is a contradiction that doubles as an admission of a specific kind of ideology, one whose guiding principle is action without inhibition. If used in this way, AI will become a tool that further cements a pattern of relating amongst groups that hinges on their being a dominant and a subordinate party. This inevitably leads to more conflict and turns any notion of AI being able to usher in a new era of prosperity and flourishing into nothing more than a clever marketing ploy.
When it comes to the debate over the use of AI in the military, two camps seem to be emerging, which I will respectively call the functionalists and the aggressionists.
Functionalists seem to advocate for AI that can reduce the cognitive load placed on military servicemen so that they can focus on tasks that are more central to their missions. Functionalists believe that human operators should still be the ones making crucial decisions.
Aggressionists share some of the same goals as the functionalists, but they are also more bold in their ambitions. This group is more likely to view the development of AI as a new Manhattan Project. Beyond improved functionality, what they are most concerned about is winning what they believe is the new global arms race, with AI as the deciding factor.
Thus far the aggressionist viewpoint seems to be winning out. The powers of the judiciary are currently being turned on Anthropic and used as leverage in their dispute with the government. Vague and innocuous phrases like “supply chain risk” are being used to brand Anthropic as a serious threat to national security. It is difficult to make the CEO of a multi-billion dollar corporation into a sympathetic figure, but that’s the point we’ve somehow arrived at in this saga.
The view that unfettered access to AI is crucial to military success is complicated by the fact that success is being defined as the ability to create lethal effects at scale. We should all be leery of following such logic.
AI should be developed in ways that serve the interests of humanity and produce the most positive good. Such outcomes are only possible if we advance beyond narrowly thinking about AI only in terms of military power.
Unraveling: Rage & Loss in Louisiana
A third of the year has gone by. Spring is here and soon we’ll be moving towards Summer. We’ll be looking forward to vacations, barbecues, swimming pools, family gatherings, but we’ll also be privy to a violence that seems to follow along with the heat and encroach upon us. These warmer months seem to make us yearn for release, and sometimes in letting go we lose control in the most tragic and consequential ways. A third of the year has gone by—there’s more sunlight and heat, but this week we are also left shuddering at the violence that overtook a sleepy little town in Louisiana called Shreveport. One where the community is left to grapple with the deadliest mass shooting in two years. A rampage that resulted in the death of eight children.
People can be insensitive in how they go about satisfying their constant wish to be entertained, but as desensitized as we sometimes are, the thought of children losing their lives is still unsettling to us. It is one of the few tragedies capable of transforming our collective appetite for entertainment fodder into collective shock and grief.
A Mind in Decline
The facts as they have been reported indicate that all of this destruction stemmed from a dissolution, a conflict or conflicts that could not be resolved and resulted in the ending of a relationship. I doubt we will ever be free of such things, lover’s quarrels and all the stress and pain that they engender, but I do know that no quarrel between lovers should ever end in murder. Most don’t, but most still leaves far too many occurrences.
I want to consider Shamar Elkins, the man who perpetrated this, not to cover him in compassion or excuse his sins—I have no interest in that, and not to flatten and erase him with narrow opinions of who he was and what he did, but to understand what he represents.
There was at least some self-awareness of the fact that he was struggling mentally. He checked himself into a facility in January. Maybe he received a modicum of care, but most mental health hospitals are only designed for short-term treatment and immediate stabilization of symptoms. They are not designed for long-term treatment with the goal of helping patients engage in meaningful depth-based psychological work that is necessary to address deeper psychological problems and improve mental health outcomes.
Like most people in those situations, Elkins was granted a short reprieve from the stressors of his life before having to return to them and was ill-equipped to handle them. It’s likely that some of these stressors were self-created, but there is still something crushing about reaching out to ask for help only to be brought back to the same problems and insurmountable consequences that brought you low in the first place. This is especially the case for men who are loath to humble themselves and admit that they are struggling.
Shortly thereafter, like many other men in these situations, Elkins seems to have abandoned the idea of ever being helped again by another person. His reaching out became public pleas for God to guard his mind and help him reject “depression, anger, anxiety, and panic.” There is an arrogance also hidden inside of the humility that allows one to rely on their faith for assistance—one that covertly expresses the belief that only a divine source is capable of helping me, not another human being. Neither arrogance or divinity prevented Elkins from trying to kill himself in February, and shortly thereafter, threatening his wife that he would try again to kill himself and their entire family if she followed through with her attempt to leave him.
There were signs that something bad could happen, but it is difficult to believe that it could ever come to this. His descent is hard to fathom, but we know now that he was clearly a man who was spiraling out of control. A week of mental health care might have forestalled the outcome, but it was not sufficient enough to prevent it. To get and stay mentally healthy requires maintenance and upkeep, otherwise we are all vulnerable to dysfunction, especially during the most difficult seasons of our lives.
The Cost
The most egregious aspect of all of this is the fact that children’s lives were either lost or changed forever. Eight children were taken. Only a 12-year old child escaped, and I wonder what exactly did she escape to? Certainly not to safety. Her life is forever altered by these events, and the fight to reclaim some level of peace and stability will be long and arduous.
“I’ve lost eight parts of me.”
That’s what Troy Brown, the father of the lone surviving child had to say about the rest of those “precious babies” he helped take care of, the ones who are now gone away.
It is difficult to understand the kind of rage that drives a man to snuff out innocence, but we know that it must be dark and cruel and terrible. It must exist outside the confines of human decency and it must be just as abhorrent as it is vicious.
Louisiana is as much my ancestral home as any other place will ever be. I know it by its contradictions—it is a place defined by its longing and its fullness, its excess and its impoverishment. A place with the best food, the nicest people, and the prettiest women, where de facto segregation still exists, where power is still hoarded, and poverty is still an institution. I am reminded on weeks like this just how unsettling it can be—the combination of all this beauty and terror.
The Governor categorized Elkin’s acts as evil, which is undoubtedly how many people feel, but once again my concern is that doing so flattens and reduces him. It absolves him and our society which produced him of responsibility. To label him as evil forces us to beg the question, how could we expect anything else from evil incarnate?
Sophia Nelson phrased it better when talking about a similar tragic event that occurred recently. “Domestic violence can occur in any family in any place.” She’s highlighting the fact that domestic violence is a social problem that is endemic, not an isolated act of evil.
If there is something that is befitting of that designation, it is the all too common belief that a relationship implies ownership. It is only within that framework, that men are able to justify and be excused for denigrating, dominating, and killing women, all in the name of keeping their entitlements.
It’s notable that while much has been said about the kind of mother Elkin’s partner was—caring, doting, loving—very little has been said about who she was as a wife. Even without that history, it’s already clear that whatever her virtues or shortcomings, none of them warranted her and her children being executed. If anything, the silence on the matter is another indictment of the many among us who upon hearing about such incidents first respond by asking, well, what did she do?
Maybe Shamar Elkins was overcome by some kind of emotional torment, some kind of temporary insanity, but it's clear he was also fueled by something else. A hatred, a sickness, a malice towards women that made him believe that he was entitled to take what was not his.
Something broke inside of him, little by little, and then all at once, or maybe nothing broke at all and whatever was inside of him was simply revealed. He could not face it so he fled from it instead and now we must, in the absence of the wicked and the innocent, carry this burden, always and forever.
Kaiser’s One Rule: Why Communication Heals
Hellmuth Kaiser was one of the first psychotherapists to recognize the significance of loneliness. To him, the problem of loneliness was so pronounced that he described it as the “universal conflict” that all men and women are bedeviled by. Man is constantly trying to overcome his feelings of isolation. Constantly trying to close the gap between himself and others and if unable to do so, then instead trying to erase his own awareness of the fact that the gap between himself and others exists.
From the universal conflict springs the “universal symptom.” Kaiser described this symptom in multiple ways. He called it duplicity, ingenuineness, and transference. What’s interesting is that while being duplicitous and being ingenuine have much in common, transference does not initially appear to be similar enough to be considered an easy replacement for either of these terms. To be duplicitous is to show certain parts of oneself while hiding other parts. All with the intent to fool others into believing something that is not true. To be ingenuine is closely related as the word simply implies a lack of sincerity or inauthenticity.
Transference, on the other hand, is understood as the displacement of unconscious feelings and wishes onto current individuals which were originally directed toward other important individuals from one’s past. This definition does not easily fit next to the others, but given Kaiser’s grouping of them, he must have thought all three terms shared basic core elements.
Is transference a form of inauthenticity? A method of being duplicitous? When you study the meaning of transference, it becomes clear that it is. To transfer thoughts and feelings, whether consciously or unconsciously, from one situation to another and treat them as though they are the same is to engage in a form of inauthentic behavior. Hence the connection between all three terms. Each of them charts a course to the same destination. A path towards an inauthentic mode of being that develops into neurosis once the underlying psychological processes and the associated behaviors have become sedimented.
Communication as the Antidote
The core focus of this essay is to examine Kaiser’s contention that the way out of this universal conflict is through communication. Kaiser believed “it was the ability to communicate freely that prevented the universal conflict.” To add clarity to this expression I would say that communicating freely implies one does not feel restricted in what they can say, regardless of whether or not they actually choose to say it. They feel unimpeded in terms of how they express themselves. Without this freedom a person enters into this universal conflict, which they compensate for by living in a state of delusion.
Communication as Kaiser saw it, was an antidote to this condition. The most positive quality of communication is not how it impacts the other, but what it does to and for the person communicating. It makes them more genuine and authentic, which allows them to resolve at least some of the issues that lead to neurosis.
Successful therapy hinges on the ability to provide this kind of space for the patient. Kaiser believed that the therapist was able to heal the patient simply by being with them.
It is of course impossible for a therapist to always guarantee they will be able to provide such a space for their patients, but there are certain characteristics common to therapists who achieve this outcome more often than not. These characteristics are having an interest in people, not having views that interfere with the therapeutic process, the absence of neuroticism, and receptiveness.
The first is self-explanatory—a genuine interest in people is a prerequisite to being an effective therapist. Secondly, the use of the term non-interfering views implies that the theoretical orientation of the therapist must support the underlying goal of the patient learning to communicate freely. If the therapist’s orientation and subsequent interventions aren’t moving the patient towards this goal it is unlikely they will achieve it on their own–if they could they would be less likely to end up in therapy in the first place.
The next characteristic also feels so intuitive that it could go without saying. It is impossible to help the patient recover from their own neurotic tendencies if the therapist is still suffering from their own. A therapist who is dealing with their own unresolved issues will have a hard time helping patients to communicate more freely. Receptiveness, the last characteristic, is closely related to this concern. As a therapist you have to stay open and receptive in order to be attuned to the patient and accurately analyze their experience. You must be able to stay aware of all the subtle ways there are for patients to engage in duplicitousness in order to help them overcome these behaviors.
Kaiser’s One Rule
Kaiser had only one rule for therapists—communicate. This was his only requirement for what therapists should do. All other dictums pertained to what therapists should be. The success of psychotherapy does not hinge solely on what the therapist does, but more so depends on who the therapist is. Psychotherapy is the process of healing someone by helping them go from isolation to relationship. The work is inherently interpersonal, therefore it is impossible to avoid considering the person of the therapist.
Through learning how to relate to the therapist without duplicity, without inauthenticity, without transference reactions, the patient inevitably changes. They grow and develop into psychological maturity. But, in order to experience the full benefits of this maturation, the therapist must at the very least possess the characteristics that were identified by Kaiser. They must be willing to move past technique and relate to the patient genuinely. Otherwise the patient’s growth is impeded.
For the patient to be able to not only experience but share in this level of genuineness and authenticity teaches them that they are also capable of generating it themselves. This is the key to the effectiveness of the therapeutic encounter. As a relationship, therapy is always temporary, but the experience of therapy can stay with the patient forever and reverberate in their lives well after the therapeutic relationship has ended.
What Kaiser is saying is that the willingness to communicate is what matters. Technique does too, to a lesser extent, but not more than the person of the therapist—the parts of themselves they bring into therapy and who they choose to show up as.
